The Higher Education Funding Council published a report on the impact of rankings in the United Kingdom. It is probably one of the most extensive studies on ranking today. The study was conducted by the Centre for Higher Education Research and Information (CHERI) and Hobsons Research and is based on a survey of 91 higher education institutions in the UK and six institutional case studies. hefce

The researchers looked at five rankings in particular, three national ones (Sunday Times Good University Guide, The Times Good University Guide, The Guardian University Guide) and two international rankings (Shanghai Rankings and the Times QS Ranking). The report itself and the background data are all available on HEFCE’s website.

Roughly, the study is divided into three parts. The first looks at rankings and their shortcomings in general. The second at the impact of rankings on universities in the UK. And the final part discusses alternative ranking methods such as the CHE ranking.

One of the most interesting questions posed in the first part is actually the same as the title of the report: counting what is measured or measuring what counts? In other words, are the criteria used in these league tables used because they are the most important determinants of quality or because those indicators are simply the ones that are (most easily) measurable? Not surprisingly, they find that:

The measures used by the compilers are largely determined by the data available rather than by clear and coherent concepts of, for example, ‘excellence’ or ‘a world class university’. Also the weightings applied do not always seem to have the desired effect on the overall scores for institutions. This brings into question the validity of the overall tables.

Several other points of critique – many of which have been discussed before, also in this blog – are confirmed in this part of the study. But the real value of the study is that it doesn’t stop here. It continues with an analyses of the survey and case studies to identify the ways in which these rankings actually shape policies. They find that institutions are indeed strongly influenced by league tables. One finding that I confirmed my expectations (see here and here) was about the link – and often contradiction – between league table criteria and other missions of the university:

League tables may conflict with other priorities. There is perceived tension between league table performance and institutional and governmental policies and concerns (e.g. on academic standards, widening participation, community engagement and the provision of socially-valued subjects). Institutions are having to manage such tensions with great care.

These are just a few quick observations. Read the full report! I will and probably post more about it at a later stage.

This article has 11 comments

  1. ???? SPECTRA 1064 ???? cosmedicbook

    ORION?????????? 755nm/1064nm/532nm??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????? -Long pulsed Nd:YAG (1064nm) -Long pulsed Alexandrite (755nm) -Long Pulsed KTP (532nm) ???? – ??????ACD? – ???? – ??? – ??? ?? -Long pulsed Nd:YAG (1064nm)???????????????????????????-Long pulsed Alexandrite (755nm)???????????????????????-Long Pulsed KTP (532nm)??????????????????????????????????

  2. ???

    CLINIQUE ???????????Clinique??????????????????????????????????????????????

  3. ???? ??

    Aki: ?????? ?????? Marie Claire (HK) Edition ??Aki?????????2016??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????

  4. air max 270

    I’m also writing to make you understand of the useful experience our child encountered browsing your site. She came to find numerous issues, including what it’s like to have a great coaching character to let the mediocre ones with ease comprehend some impossible things. You really surpassed our desires. Many thanks for coming up with those informative, healthy, edifying and easy thoughts on the topic to Ethel.

  5. adidas yeezy

    I’m writing to let you understand what a incredible experience my wife’s girl undergone checking your blog. She figured out a wide variety of issues, which include how it is like to possess a very effective helping nature to let the rest with ease have an understanding of certain complex subject matter. You actually surpassed our desires. Thanks for giving these helpful, trusted, revealing and as well as fun thoughts on this topic to Gloria.

  6. jordan 13

    I as well as my buddies have been reading through the excellent tactics found on the website and then instantly developed a terrible feeling I had not thanked the site owner for those strategies. The guys are already certainly passionate to read all of them and now have actually been enjoying them. Many thanks for really being considerably considerate and also for settling on this kind of superior issues millions of individuals are really desirous to know about. Our honest regret for not expressing gratitude to sooner.

  7. adidas outlet

    I enjoy you because of your whole hard work on this site. My mom take interest in doing internet research and it’s obvious why. We know all of the lively form you make very helpful steps on this blog and in addition increase contribution from others on that issue and our favorite child is certainly starting to learn a great deal. Enjoy the remaining portion of the year. Your performing a good job.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.